In fall 2011, the church's roof was replaced with shingles matching the restroom and entryway. At the end of 2011, with a grant from the Northern Ohio District of the Church of the Brethren, construction began on a new sign featuring a board with changeable letters to better welcome new guests. Construction of the sign concluded in 2012.

In late 2013, the church's main level carpet was replaced and the pews were recovered. The Fellowship Building also had two new furnaces installed.

New windows were installed in 2016 on the front and balcony area of the church along with the redo of the carport beams. The remaining six sanctuary windows were replaced in 2017 with a donation from the family of Helen Driver.